Review of "Classic App Switcher" version 3.1 (14)

Details Page Preview

Classic App Switcher is a 🖱️ Mouse friendly application switcher for GNOME inspired by the classic Mac OS. The minimal design blends discreetly into the GNOME UI, providing a familiar workflow for users transitioning from macOS while respecting GNOME's design principles. **Key Features:** - Panel button shows the currently focused application and opens a menu with window management functions - Lists running applications on the current workspace - Easily hide an app and retrieve all of its open windows - Hide all other apps/windows allowing you to focus on the active window - Window count showing visible and hidden (or minimized) windows and apps - Workspace-isolated behaviour for fluid multi-workspace workflows - Complements native GNOME features (Activities, Dash, Dynamic Workspaces) - New in v2.0: Panel Button Scroll - Scroll DOWN to toggle between focused application and most recent below. Scroll UP to cycle through open application stack in reverse order (back-to-front - requires at least 3x open apps!) - New in v2.0: Optional Mac Style keyboard shortcut support! - New in v3.0: Right-Click Context Menu - Access Dash App Menu and Action List and see all open windows of the current app directly from the panel indicator - New in v3.0: Workspace Switcher - Quickly move applications or windows between workspaces via context menu (hold Alt to send without switching workspace) - New in v3.0: Overview Effects - Optional visual effects for minimized and hidden windows in Activities Overview - New in v3.0: Hide from Overview - Optionally exclude hidden windows from Activities Overview for a cleaner workspace - New in v3.0: Middle-Click panel indicator to quick launch new window in supported apps

Extension Homepage
https://github.com/mr-pixel-dev/classic-app-switcher

No comments.

Diff Against

Files

Note: Binary files aren't shown on the web site. To see all files, please download the extension zipfile.

Shexli (experimental) error 1

Shexli found 1 issue that may need reviewer attention.

EGO-M-004 error

metadata shell-version must only include plausible stable releases and at most one development release

Field `shell-version` contains invalid values, more than one development release, or implausible future releases.

metadata.json must be well-formed

  • metadata.json
    shell-version=['46', '47', '48', '49', '50', '51']

All Versions

Version Status
3.1 (14) Active
3.0 (13) Active
3.0 (12) Rejected
3.0 (11) Rejected
2.1 (10) Active
2.1 (9) Active
2.0 (8) Active
2.0 (7) Rejected
2.0 (6) Rejected
1.0 (5) Active
1.0 (4) Rejected
1.0 (3) Rejected
1.0 (2) Rejected
1.0 (1) Rejected

Previous Reviews on this Version

JustPerfection rejected
1. Please remove AI generated comments. 2. Use icons instead of emjoi: [Extension Best Practices Guidelines: Icons vs. Emojis](https://gjs.guide/extensions/review-guidelines/best-practices.html#ui-elements-icons-vs-emojis) Please avoid sending large diff. It can wait even for months since the review queue is very busy.
Mr Pixel posted a review
Thanks, i appreciate the diff was on the large side but that was mostly cleaning house! Changes were limited to a specific file by and large. The Emoji I assume are those in the prefs popover which have been present since v2.0 but I am happy to remove them as they were intended as an amusing easter egg! Regarding your claim of AI comments - not sure what you are referring to here, perhaps you could inform me what/where because these files have been checked by hand and other then the JSDoc stuff there should be no AI smell here! Regards
JustPerfection posted a review
For comments, usually AI uses number for comments: - Line 32, 36 `eventHandlers.js` - Line 90 `settings/legalPage.js`
Mr Pixel posted a review
Are you serious? 3 lines with numbered comments? Looking at these clearly I missed them during cleanup. Given the legalPage.js does nothing other than display a Gtk.TextView and the two comments in eventHandlers.js are followed by two more WITHOUT numbers - using this to determine = AI is absurd. You have chosen to reject what is otherwise a clean and well tested update to an EXISTING extension over this? You also flag an icon issue when it does not apply here given it is not a case of using improper patterns as I cannot substitute this with an icon nor would an icon be the most appropriate choice here. I am actually lost for words, quite frankly this is completely ridiculous.
JustPerfection active
Didn't reject for comments really. The emoji was the reason but since that emoji usage was intentionally made by human, I approve this. BTW, please note, seeing AI practices in extensions is really making the review process hard for us. If you've missed the blog post, I recommend reading that: https://blogs.gnome.org/jrahmatzadeh/2026/10/12/help-ego-team/